ShelfDog Compare prices ›

Grocery prices in New York · NJ · CT

Which store is cheapest in New York · NJ · CT? We compare 20 stores here every day.

The same basket of 5 basics at each store

2% milk, 1 gallon, Large eggs, 12 count, White sandwich bread, Butter, 1 lb (salted), Creamy peanut butter, 16 oz

Lidl Park Ridge (web price)$10.99
Lidl Howell Township (web price)$10.99
Lidl Brooklyn (web price)$10.99
Lidl New York (web price)$10.99
Lidl Fresh Meadows (web price)$10.99
Lidl Pelham (web price)$10.99
Lidl Staten Island (web price)$10.99
Lidl Totowa (web price)$10.99
Lidl Union (web price)$10.99
ShopRite Brooklyn McDonald Ave$14.05
ShopRite Paramus$14.12
ShopRite Monroe$14.45
Stop & Shop Monroe$14.65
Stop & Shop New Rochelle$14.65
Whole Foods Middletown$22.91
Whole Foods Paramus$23.02
Whole Foods Stamford$23.02
Whole Foods Columbus Circle$23.65
Whole Foods Jericho$24.35

Popular items: lowest price in NY/NJ/CT

Compare at stores near me

Stores we compare

Prices as of November 8, 2026.